Migration routes seem a little misleading, and generic |
Info on my Sardinian migration route when clicking on one of the map markers (above) |
GPS Origins claims the migration route include "precision targeting—sometimes down to the village or town" which is a gross exaggeration. The map markers may look precise, but when you read the info attached to it, you can see it's not that specific.
The results in Sardinia, Fennoscandia, and Western Siberia are a little off to begin with. I'm getting 21.5% in Fennscandia, 11.7% in Sardinia, and 11.6% in Western Siberia. I do have Scandinavian roots in Norway, but it should only about 12.5%. The Sardinia results are probably coming from my Italian ancestry, but peaking in Sardinia doesn't seem right. As for Western Siberia, I have no ancestry there at all.
My ethnicity percentages |
#1 Fennoscandia 21.5%
Origin: Peaks in the Iceland and Norway and declines in Finland, England, and France
#2 Sardinia 11.7%
Origin: Peaks in Sardinia and declines in weaker in Italy, Greece, Albania, and The Balkans
#3 Western Siberia 11.6%
Origin: Peaks in Krasnoyarsk Krai and declines towards east Russia
#4 Orkney Islands 11.5%
Origin: Peaks in the Orkney islands and declines in England, France, Germany, Belarus, and Poland
#5 Southern France 9.9%
Origin: Peaks in south France and declines in north France, England, Orkney islands, and Scandinavia
Why are they talking about Y and mtDNA in my autosomal DNA results? |
Origin: Peaks in France and Spain Basque regions and declines in Spain, France, and Germany
#7 Tuva 8.1%
Origin: Peaks in south Siberia (Russians: Tuvinian) and declines in North Mongolia
#8 Southeastern India 5.4%
Origin: Endemic to south eastern india with residues in Pakistan
#9 Northern India 5%
Origin: Peaks in North India (Dharkars, Kanjars) and declines in Pakistan
#10 The Southern Levant 3%
Origin: This gene pool is localized to Israel with residues in Syria
#11 Arabia 1.6%
Origin: Peaks in Saudi Arabia and Yemen and declines in Israel, Jordan, Iraq, and Egypt
#12 Northwestern Africa 1.1%
Origin: Peaks in Algeria and declines in Morocco and Tunisia
#13 Western South America 0.3%
Origin: Peaks in Peru, Mexico, and North America and declines in Eastern Russia
You can compare this with my results from other companies here.
The Legal Genealogist says GPS Origins is one not to bother with, and based on this I would agree. I definitely would discourage anyone from buying a test with them, considering it costs $199 compared to the more popular DNA companies charging $99 or less. You're basically paying twice the amount to get inferior ethnicity reports and no DNA matching with other testers. As for the $39 upload, it may be worth it for curiosity sake, but don't expect much from it. I found it very disappointing.
Here's another thorough review from another blogger.
No comments:
Post a Comment